neevebrody ([info]neevebrody) wrote in [info]mcsheplets,

Challenge Fic: The Last Word (or When You See With My Eyes) (G)

Written for the #26 Challenge - Last

Title: The Last Word (or when you see with my eyes)
Author: [info]neevebrody
Characters: John, Rodney, Jennifer
Rating: G
Words: ~3,500
Spoilers: Possible spoilers for Last Man
Beta: [info]velocitygrass beta'd this even though she doesn't usually read this type of fic. Your thoughts and approval really meant a lot to me, hon, thank you so very much. Updated version beta'd by [info]mischief5 - all remaining errors are mine.
AN/Warnings: This story is loosely based on the film, The Final Cut, written and directed by Omar Naim. Character death is mentioned but the death does not occur in the fic.
Summary: He's already late, yet he still sits there, kneading the steering wheel until it warms his palms. John Sheppard, big damn hero. Able to face countless enemies without flinching, but not his own fears or the ghosts of his past.

ETA: See the brilliant fic cover by [info]pixiequeen10thk HERE

The Last Word (when you see with my eyes)


John cants his arm, allowing the day's mail to cascade onto the coffee table. Juggling a sandwich in one hand, a bottle of beer and the remote in the other, he sits down. A dark, navy blue envelope, magically separated from the bills and circulars, catches his eye, begging to be opened first.

He puts his sandwich back on the plate and takes a long pull from the beer. Wiping his hands over his thighs, he picks up the envelope, turning it over carefully. It's not the first one he's received over the years but, this time, he suspects he knows the name he'll find inside. And it makes opening it that much harder.

The distinctive black and white logo on the return address is easily recognizable. Lyrres Systems, Ltd. These days, you'd have to be from another planet not to know about Lyrres and the DigiChron implant. Touted as one of the largest socio-technological advancements in history, second only to personal computing, the company has manufactured personal memory chips for human implantation for over twenty years. Tiny electronic wonders that record and store every thought, every action, every word… every second of an individual's life.

John slides a finger just underneath the flap, then backs off.

Rodney had done some consulting work for Lyrres after leaving the Atlantis "mission" —as it had come to be known near the end. John hasn't thought of that in years, but he vividly recalls the day Rodney and Jennifer left the city. They were the only ones from his original team who remained after the scientists were ordered back to Earth. They'd both received special dispensation from the SGC to stay but, like Teyla and some of the others, they'd quickly become disillusioned with the new thrust of the expedition as a purely military operation. Ronon, who would only swear allegiance to John and to Atlantis, was forced out by the SGC and had left the city some time earlier. Afterward, whenever he and John fought alongside one another, it was as allies instead of teammates.

John had stayed on longer, of course. At first, just to wrap things up and turn over command, but there'd been a little snafu in that plan with the rumblings coming from the Arkturans and rumors of their takeover of neighboring planets. By the time that situation had been diffused, he'd learned of Rodney's marriage to Jennifer.

He'd stayed on, then, at least until the colonization and "nation building," rife in the wake of the Wraith's demise, had become too much for even him to stomach.

When John did return to Earth, he was happy to resume old friendships and settled down in Weston, Washington, the same town where Rodney and Jennifer had made their home. It hadn't taken long; he and Rodney had fallen back into an easy and familiar routine, and John soon realized just how much he'd missed that companionship.

Rodney seemed happier than John ever remembered. He'd put that down to Rodney's life with Jennifer. It certainly wasn't their morning jogs. Even through all the huffing and bitching, John was proud to have finally convinced Rodney to pay more attention to his health.

They would spend hours at a time talking about what Atlantis had become and bemoaning the fate of the Pegasus Galaxy. Both agreed that those whose job it was to combat the enemy had become the enemy in the end, and neither of them were surprised to learn of the eventual closure and declassification of the Pegasus project.

It was during one of those discussions that Rodney had confided to John about his DigiChron implant. Rodney told of his participation in the prototype testing during his early affiliation with the Air Force. His consulting contract with Lyrres, the company that later took over the program for use in the private sector, was limited to the development of the process used to recover and sort the recorded memories.

John rips through the dark blue seal. As expected, the name printed in Lyrres' distinctive, block print on the white cardstock invitation reads: M. Rodney McKay, PhD, PhD.

Even though he can't suppress his grin – Rodney never let anyone forget about that second distinction – John feels unsettled at seeing the words. For obvious reasons and because he hasn't called Jennifer since the funeral.

Scanning the invitation, he notes the date, time, and location of the Remembrance. God, he hates that term, it's so damned pretentious. The worldwide cultural fascination with the DigiChip may be phenomenal but John abhors the concept of the implant, always has.

Parents even fit their newborns with the implants now – The Lifetime Plan they call it – sometimes going into debt to do so. So proud, yet never thinking of their child's reaction once they've reached the age of consent – the age Lyrres recommends they be told about their chip – to the violation of their privacy and the privacy of others, recorded and cataloged without their permission. It's not surprising that the latest statistics reference a marked increase in the suicide rate among chip owners between the ages of twenty-one to twenty-eight. A fact John's sure Lyrres doesn't publicize in its prospectus or the annual reports to its stockholders.

Though one thing puzzles John about the invitation, both Rodney and Jennifer were aware of his views. He can understand Jennifer holding a Remembrance, but inviting him? These rituals are mental scrapbooks, party favors for the grieving and the hangers on. They're celebrations of the events and moments of a person's life quickly forcing the standard funeral service into the realm of the passé.
Customarily celebrated as lavish social events by the more affluent, in recent years the costs of the implant and cutting, as the process of digitizing the data is known, have been reduced to provide the service to as many people as want it. And a lot of people want it.

Rodney had once explained the process of what happens after death, and the recovery of the implant. John takes another pull from his beer and tries not to think of it in relation to his friend. After extraction, the data is read and digitally processed by what is known in the trade as a Cutter. That person's job is to sort and sift through a person's processed memories – everything neatly categorized into subfiles: hygiene, personal interaction, sleep, dreams, thoughts, sex – and painstakingly select those memories that most reflect and represent the deceased person's life (or the life the family wishes to remember). This selection process, the Cutter's choice of memories to work from, is normally accomplished through interviews with family and friends, but can also be done by bequest of the individual, not unlike the making of a will. In the past, families had carefully and lovingly selected a casket or burial plot for their loved one. Now, they select a good Cutter.

Cutters vary in talent, experience, and affordability, with a few reaching god-like acclaim for their skills. There are those who specialize in the rich and famous, and those who cut for the masses. A good Cutter can earn a decent living, but a truly talented one can earn a fortune for the skilled crafting and presentation of a person's life remembered.

John stares at the invitation. He's already thinking up reasons that will prevent him from attending when the postscript grabs his attention: As a final wish, Dr. McKay personally requests your presence at this event. John snorts at the idea of Rodney arranging his own Remembrance, though somehow that really doesn't surprise him. He can just imagine the guest list and what they'll all be in for, a parade of Rodney's brilliance mixed with images and memories of his life with Jennifer and the kids.

John closes his eyes. Another swallow of beer chases down the lump in his throat. The last thing he wants right now is to sit through their life, but those words echo in his head, almost as if they were uttered in Rodney's own high-tensile like voice: final wish. John takes a long cleansing breath. He'd never denied Rodney anything in life… he isn't about to start now.

~~~~

The Remembrance Hall at Stone Station is a large, modern, single-story stucco building at the end of a wending, tree-lined drive. The grounds are meticulously landscaped and groomed. Lyrres, a company that could likely buy and sell the Earth several times over, had spared no expense on this location.

The parking lot is jammed but then this hall boasts four Viewing Rooms. Spying an empty space, John wheels in and checks his watch. He's already late, yet he still sits there, kneading the steering wheel until it warms his palms. John Sheppard, big damn hero. Able to face countless enemies without flinching, but not his own fears or the ghosts of his past.

Viewing Room 2 is already dark and he slips into a seat at the back. By his thinking, he's already satisfied Rodney's wishes: he's here, he's just not promising for how long. The only other Remembrance he'd ever attended left him creeped out for days and he wants a clear shot to bolt if he has to.

The rooms are something of a cross between high-tech digital theaters and chapels. They're modernly ornate, but equipped with every technological advancement in digital entertainment: floor-to-ceiling high definition LCD screens and surround sound so real it's like having the departed back with you. The showing has already begun and the screen is filled with early memories of Rodney's life. His life as a child, his parents and Jeannie. Good to know there was never a time when Rodney was not bossy, there's some kind of cosmic order there somewhere. The scenes move by in succession and John's really not absorbing it all until—

Startled by his own voice, he looks up to see the gateroom of Atlantis. Seven hundred and twenty... Yes. I knew that of course. I'm just surprised you did… Take away the coordinates you can't get a lock on, and that's your one. He grins, remembering how satisfying that little exchange had been.

For the next few minutes, John sits through Rodney's hand-picked memories of his life in Atlantis, interspersed with those from his life afterward. Rodney must have paid the Cutter a fortune. The progression is swift but seamless, and after watching a few more moments, it occurs to John how many times his own face appears on the screen and how often he hears his own voice.

He winces at seeing himself bound to a chair, being fed upon by Todd, then stares into his own frightened eyes as Rodney begs permission to sacrifice himself to the very same Wraith. His heart races at Rodney's words, just as if it was happening all over again.

A succession of small, innocuous moments flash by, memories of Rodney's 'family' in Atlantis: laughter, tears, and oh, wow, Torren John! He huffs a laugh at Rodney's grating consternation that his brain is not a new deck on the back of John's house, at the same time recalling the pain of almost losing Rodney. So serious at the time, and yet brains and power tools became a running joke for them after a few years.

The screen flickers dark then brightens again with Jennifer's face, dancing with Rodney at their wedding. She looks so happy. Then a cut to a very small, wrinkled, and red face screaming up at him as Rodney holds his son in his arms for the first time. John swallows hard as Rodney's awe-filled voice showers him with chills. Welcome to the world, John Graham McKay.

Again, the memories start to move quickly: a flurry of baby John taking his first steps, his first words, Jennifer pregnant, John again, a diaper-clad computer genius in the making, the birth of another child, Rodney's daughter Jeannie.

An empty knot twists itself inside John's stomach as the memories start to slow down. Black screen and then—

Another younger version of himself. They're clearly off-world and he appears to be sleeping. The location might be familiar but for all the planets in Pegasus looking pretty much the same at night. It must be Rodney's watch. He mumbles something but John can't make it out, just sits frozen in place, barely breathing as Rodney reaches down to smooth the hair back from the younger John's face.

He feels the pinch of his shirt collar and fingernails mark his palms with tiny crescents as Rodney bends closer and closer. Another low mumble and then the soft whisper of Rodney's lips against that John's temple.

Jesus.

He doesn't even try to blink the sting from the corners of his eyes. Just stares helplessly, chest heavy from lack of air. Finally, John struggles to take a breath. If he's going to run, now's the time, but he can't. It feels as if the floor is falling away beneath him, threatening to drop him into the abyss below if he moves. Still reeling, he takes another blow as the next memory, one more recent, hits him hard.

What do you mean you're not happy, Rodney? Look at you – you've got a decent job, couldn't ask for a better family. How long have you felt like this?

A long time. I don't know, it's just this feeling of wishing I'd done things differently—

That's just you getting old, buddy. Hey, the Nobel Committee is going to wise up one of these—

It's—it's more than that. I—there's something that I should have done a long time ago, things I should have said that I didn't and now, well, now I—

Don't do that. Hell, we all have regrets. They'll eat your ass alive if you let them. Look, go home, hug the kids, and try again with Jennifer. She loves you and I'm sure when you come out of this funk you're in, you'll see that you love her, too.

But, John, I… never mind. Of course, you're right. Of course.


The words may as well be painted in red behind his eyelids... of course, you're right.

He doesn't watch the next sequence of scenes, but he can tell they're soccer games and debates, prom dates and driving lessons, arguments and advice. He just wants it over, wants the blood to stop pounding in his ears.

When everything goes quiet again, he opens his eyes. The knot in his stomach pulls tighter as Rodney stares back at him, or rather, Rodney's reflection. John always thought he'd aged better than the hologram version but the same deep wrinkles from years of stress and concentration lined Rodney's handsome face. His hair, most of which was still there, distinguished by streaks of silver.
The shock of looking into those blue eyes again catches John's breath. Eyes he could always read so well, or so he thought. How was it he missed the sadness he sees there now?

On the screen, Rodney enters the bedroom and takes a box from his closet. As the lid comes off, John's looking into it along with Rodney. It seems full of the last remnants of Atlantis, things the sentimental soul in Rodney had squirreled away.

Among the items crowded in the box are the patches belonging to Grodin, Dumais, Gaul, Abrahms, and other scientists who died during the expedition; the tattered photograph of Rodney and Carson, curled and creased out of its frame; the Wraith necklace Ronon had given him the day he'd left Atlantis; a picture drawn by Torren with the words for Uncle Rodney scrawled at the top. A tight smile breaks through when he recognizes the Czech to English translation manual. He'd always suspected it.

He watches as Rodney takes something from the box. John's confused for a moment but then… he remembers, now, and that sets his heart pounding again. He'd given Rodney some personal items to take back to Earth, thinking he'd follow them soon.

The memory seems to slow down as Rodney's thumb strokes the small face of a boy, all smiles, standing beside his hero. He utters one last word before the screen goes dark for good: John.

As the lights start to come up, John's finally able to move. He stands, blinking rapidly, turning to get out quickly before anyone notices him. It's only then he realizes there's only one other person in the room besides the Cutter. Jennifer rises slowly as the man walks over and hands her something. They speak but John can't hear what they're saying. Whatever it is, Jennifer shakes her head, and then she sees him. They stare at one another for a moment before she turns back to the Cutter, takes the object from his hand, and walks up the aisle.

He tries not to look into her red-rimmed eyes. "Jennifer, I—I didn't…"

The soft shushing noise quiets him. "I know that. If you had known, my children and I might not have been a part of this."

"I refuse to believe that," he said, pointing emphatically. "Rodney loved you." Oh God, he did… didn't he?

"Maybe. I believe he loved the kids." Bright, unshed tears well in the corners of her eyes. "I think it's obvious he loved you," she adds, slowly meeting John's gaze again. She tries to hand him what the Cutter had given her. It's a small, clear plastic square about the size of his palm.

"What's this?"

"The replicate. It's a copy of the original cut, what they use for the showings."

John shakes his head and pushes it back toward her.

"Don't you see, John? This is more than memories. It's a love letter, only it's not for me."

He opens his mouth to say something then closes it, tugging at his collar instead.

"But it does answer a few questions I've had over the years and I'm sure that's why it was his wish that only you and I see it."

"Jennifer, I really don't—"

She takes John's hand and presses the small square firmly into it. "No, this is for you. You know how he always liked to have the last word." She offers a passable smile. "This is him saying... in case you missed it, moron."

John trembles a little, but Jennifer's hand is warm. He tries to smile back, but then she gathers him into a hug. "Take care of yourself."

"I'm sorry." They're hollow words spoken into her hair while he thinks through the haze whether to pat her shoulder, and though he means it, he ends up just standing there.

"Don't be." She pulls back, her face serious again. "I always knew something was missing, that after a while he wasn't happy. I believed it was my fault even though he always denied it. This was Rodney's way of finally making me see it had nothing to do with me." She lets go of him and takes a step back, pressing a tissue to her nose. "Don't be a stranger, huh? The kids would be thrilled to see you and John's asked more than once about those flying lessons you promised to set up."

He nods absently.

She kisses his cheek. "Good-bye, John."

When the door closes, he takes a deep breath and stares at the plastic square. In his hand, he holds everything in the world that was important to Rodney, with himself front and center. He wonders how many other times Rodney had tried in his own way to tell him. He starts to think back but catches himself – thinking of his own chances to tell Rodney how he felt, what he wanted. Chances he'd chosen not to take.

Settling, instead, for something he knew he already had and something he could never do without, Rodney's friendship. While Rodney and Jennifer's relationship hadn't happened exactly as the hologram Rodney had described, John had made sure in the end that they would get together, always thinking it was what Rodney had wanted, never saying anything to either of them about what he'd learned from that sad-faced old man in the future.

He makes his way down to the front of the room where the Cutter, a lanky gentleman dressed in a custom-cut suit and smelling of cigars, stands awaiting instruction. After a moment, John hands him the replicate. "Would you mind running this again, please?"

Stone-faced, the Cutter takes the silicone repository. His accent is thick and elegant. "Certainly, sir," he replies before making his way back to the console.

John takes a seat in the front row, hands curling around the arms of the chair as the room drips dark around him. Seconds later, the screen brightens with Rodney's life flickering before him. Now, it's just the two of them again. One last time.

In a rush of emotion that seems to consume him and liberate him all at once, John realizes there was something he had denied Rodney, something he had denied himself and, with that, he lets go. His whole body limp as he closes his eyes and lets Rodney embrace him with the sound of his voice.



Now, read the sequel: Past Perfect

Tags: author: neevebrody, challenge: 26 - last, genre: angst, genre: pining/unrequited, pairing: john/rodney, rating: g

  • Post a new comment

    Error

  • 125 comments
Previous
← Ctrl← Alt
Next
Ctrl →Alt →

[info]helenkacan

August 25 2008, 19:58:39 UTC 3 years ago

I think you've achieved the impossible here: you made me feel sympathy for Jennifer. And I'm thinking how crushingly bittersweet to be the only other person at your husband's Remembrance, together with the one he really loved.

And John, knowing what only he knew from The Last Man, let Rodney have that other life.

I'm starting to cry and have this sharp ache in my chest, just thinking about it (um, maybe that's my own personal angst kicking in, but your story was the catalyst). Usually, I thank people for their fic; so, am I supposed to thank you for making me cry? ::is uncertain::

Anyway, if this story is a spoiler for anything, I'd say The Last Man more than anything else. And forgive me if the chip gives me the creeeeeeeps!

Weepy hugs,
H.

[info]neevebrody

August 25 2008, 20:17:19 UTC 3 years ago

I'm just not sure why my angst button is "always on" lately, but I wanted to write a story about complex feelings and like I said, I had already formed and written most of the story before viewing The Shrine. After thinking about that ep, I sort of went, "wow" and knew that even though a lot of people don't want the angst right now, I had to finish it and post it. So very sorry to make you hurty. I think we all put a bit of ourselves into our writing, even with the boys, and that's a fair statement here.

I'll add a spoiler for Last Man, thanks. The chip is supposed to give you the creeps, especially when you think, it could be possible. *puts on tinfoil hat*

Warm consoling hugs,
N

[info]moonstonerose

August 25 2008, 20:13:07 UTC 3 years ago

You made me cry. It's a beautiful story with a heartbreaking ending. I'm left thinking about might have been.

[info]neevebrody

August 25 2008, 20:20:18 UTC 3 years ago

Not glad I made you cry, but I am glad that you thought it was a beautiful story. Even though I know it's not what most people want to read right now, the complexity of this story is what grabbed me and made me write it. Thank you.

[info]tarlanx

August 25 2008, 20:24:24 UTC 3 years ago

I don't really like death fics so I was very wary of reading it... and though I still didn't like it being a death fic, it was such a well written but infinitely sad story of a love lost and a life wasted despite the lovely kids. I'm going to have to go find a happy fic now or I'll be miserable for the rest of the evening.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 01:06:25 UTC 3 years ago

I hope you found some happy fic! Thank you for your lovely comments and I'm glad you read the story even though you don't like this type. I couldn't get the idea of this out of my head and wanted to write a complicated relationship piece, but one that was real, or felt real to me. Thanks again, hon.

[info]sgakaz

August 25 2008, 21:18:25 UTC 3 years ago

It was beautiful and so sad I wish Rodney had been braver and told John the truth instead of going back to Jennifer and he would still have had the kids as I am sure Jen would not have stopped him seeing them, IE. she seemed to understand at the end.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 01:08:50 UTC 3 years ago

Thank you so much for your lovely comments. Yes, this one was all about the 'what ifs'. I believe Jennifer knew all along she didn't have all of Rodney's heart. I'm glad you enjoyed the story.

[info]erda_3

August 25 2008, 21:41:48 UTC 3 years ago

Meep! I don't know what to say.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 01:10:06 UTC 3 years ago

I know! I hope you mean that in a good way. ;)

[info]chandri

August 25 2008, 21:42:45 UTC 3 years ago

...oh. I just... oh. *sniff*

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 01:11:16 UTC 3 years ago

Aw, *hands you tissues* Thanks so much for reading, I'm glad you enjoyed it.

[info]tzzzz

August 25 2008, 21:46:47 UTC 3 years ago

That was beautifully written and heartbreaking. Thanks for sharing.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 01:11:40 UTC 3 years ago

Thank you so much. I'm very glad you enjoyed it!

[info]mrshamill

August 26 2008, 00:06:57 UTC 3 years ago

How is this page not filled with comments? This is probably the most heartrending, brilliantly executed and TRUE piece of writing I've seen in ages. It's absolutely perfect. I guessed about a quarter of the way into it where you were heading, but you took me there with such grace and subtlety that I didn't care, even though I knew I was heading for tears, I didn't care.

This was incredible. Thank you.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 01:17:24 UTC 3 years ago

God, you have me blushing madly. Thank you so very much for your kind comments. I feel my warning may have scared a few people away, but felt I needed to be honest, especially now when so much is going on in the fandom. I'm very glad you enjoyed this story. I wanted to write a complex relationship piece with real emotions and I'm very flattered that you feel I succeeded. Thank you again.

[info]eotu

August 26 2008, 00:34:20 UTC 3 years ago

This is beautiful. Achingly sad, and exquisitely beautiful. You render the pain of might-have-been so well, for all three characters.

In addition, it's damned fine science fiction. Do you know how hard it is to get true human feeling and science into the same story? Well, you did it! If I saw this published in one of the magazines, I'd nominate it for a Hugo.

This story will haunt me for days, in the best possible way.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 01:23:45 UTC 3 years ago

Thank you so much for your lovely comments. I love it when a fic haunts me and that's what I set out to do here. I'm very glad you enjoyed it.

But, I can't take much credit for the science fiction. As I said in my notes, the story is based on the movie The Final Cut, which was brilliantly written and directed by Omar Naim. If you've never seen the film, I would recommend it. It, too, is haunting. I futzed around with the name of the chip and such, but the concept - a memory chip implant and the "showings" (or retelling/revamping) "cutting" of a person's life is all Mr. Naim's.

[info]mischief5

August 26 2008, 01:21:17 UTC 3 years ago

I don't know what to say to this. The humanity is beautifully flawed, beautifully real, and the science is so possible and creepy. This is like the best of Heinlein's short stories.

I can see this playing out this way: John being so selfish in his selflessness, Rodney settling for second best, and Jennifer living the dream until reality finally intrudes. How sad and how very human.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 01:32:45 UTC 3 years ago

It is, if you will, a very "human condition" type story, which as you've pointed out, is canonically accurate. John is long suffering and maybe he's waiting on... something - and in the meantime, Jennifer is smitten and uses that against a relationally immature Rodney, whose enthralled with a wonderful woman like Keller being interested in him. People make the wrong decisions and there's always consequences. Some people say screw the consequences and some, like Rodney, would always do the "right" thing.

And thank you for the compliment on the science, but as I said in my notes - the basic concept here is based on The Final Cut, a film written and directed by Omar Naim. If you've never seen it, I would recommend it. Robin Williams is fabulous and creepy as the Cutter and the whole "cultural" thing is done so well in the film.

Again, thanks for your comments and I'm very glad you enjoyed the story.

[info]accidentalfan

August 26 2008, 02:02:01 UTC 3 years ago

Just so gorgeous and heart-breaking. The sheer weight of that missed opportunity is so immense. (And the memory chips are a really interesting premise.) Very well done.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 15:55:57 UTC 3 years ago

Thank you so much for your lovely comments. I like how you put it, the weight of missed opportunity. That's it exactly for John now. I'm glad you enjoyed the story.

[info]darsynia

August 26 2008, 03:31:31 UTC 3 years ago

This is a work of art. The thing is, with all the alternate universes we've been shown, we're hardly ever shown one where things go absolutely perfectly--more often, we're shown ones where slight differences change the scope of everyone's lives, and not always for the better. I'm reminded of The Road Not Traveled, here, in your use of the chip. Subtler, but still.

There's a story that's cut a swathe through my heart ever since I read it, a story that was very, very good but still hurt. It's the 'Hundred Words For Snow' story. In an odd way, you've made it all better. Not to give too much away for that story, there are decisions made and not made in both, and ironically, it's the frightening reality of that chip that soothes away the unrequited love-pain that happens in stories like this.

I love that Rodney's imperfect, here. That he is selfish enough to name his son John--not even necessarily that it's a conscious selfishness, either, and I think that Jennifer knows that, too. In my fanon for this story, Rodney tells himself that it's okay to shy away from the tough decisions, it's okay to deny himself, because he knows there are alternate universes out there, and for the number of times he's snagged himself on indecision (go to John and tell him, or stay where I am and appreciate what I have?) over the years, in each instance there's a reality where he's given in. He's told himself he has to content himself with that knowledge.

I almost want to write a Rodney PoV view to that effect, heh.

Anyway, I really, really love this, thank you so much for writing it, truly.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 16:13:30 UTC 3 years ago

because he knows there are alternate universes out there, and for the number of times he's snagged himself on indecision (go to John and tell him, or stay where I am and appreciate what I have?) over the years, in each instance there's a reality where he's given in. He's told himself he has to content himself with that knowledge.

This is a wonderful premise and would make a lovely long and complex fic. I'm kind of awe-struck at your kind words and I'm so glad you enjoyed the story. I honestly think if more people gave it a look and didn't immediately shy away from "death!fic" they'd see how much love is shown. Yes, it does hurt, and nobody escapes unscathed, with is real. And I know this is supposed to be "escape" stuff, but I honestly could not sit through the Shrine and study over it without thinking how much John and Rodney love and need each other, but at the same time how easily it would be for John to remain stoic (in light of what he learned in Last Man), for Rodney to make a wrong decision based on infatuation, and for Jennifer to be selfish enough to ignore what she surely sees as well to "let" Rodney make a wrong decision. I hope more people will give it a chance, but...

I'm really glad you did and I thank you!

[info]neevebrody

3 years ago

[info]darsynia

3 years ago

[info]neevebrody

3 years ago

[info]ex_kisa_haw

August 26 2008, 03:40:18 UTC 3 years ago

This is gorgeous, and so sad, and exactly what I've been looking for in the turmoil of fandom lately.

Lovely and well done.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 22:55:42 UTC 3 years ago

Thank you so much for your comments. I know everyone prefers happy, but actually I've found the fics that stay with me the most are the ones that hurt, especially like here where you have an opportunity that never had a chance to be what the reader knows it could have been. I'm so glad you enjoyed it.

[info]gilesbabe

August 26 2008, 04:46:41 UTC 3 years ago

There is nothing I can say that others haven't already. This is strong, beautiful, and so painful.

To quote a Rupert Holmes song "The saddest words that anyone has ever said are 'what might have been', but no one said you get to win."

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 16:14:55 UTC 3 years ago

Oh God, that quote is so true. I'm really glad you enjoyed the story and I thank you very much for reading.

[info]winter_elf

August 26 2008, 07:28:58 UTC 3 years ago

*sobs!!* Oh god, Rodney, why, why, why. Heartbreaking for John to find out after, some strong denial going on there! I'm glad they stayed friends, but so much not said. The science was pretty darn creepy.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 16:35:19 UTC 3 years ago

This story is so much about things left unsaid and decisions not made. John satisfies himself with a known quantity - Rodney's friendship, never thinking he could have had more and Rodney made a wrong decision, but never forgot about what he really wanted. I'm really glad you enjoyed it and I thank you for reading.

[info]torchwood_3

August 26 2008, 10:17:41 UTC 3 years ago

Wow...just wow. If there's one thing that can always get to me, it's regret and this is just chock full of it. Hehe *sobs*

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 16:36:02 UTC 3 years ago

It is that, indeed. Thank you so much for reading and I'm really glad you enjoyed it.

[info]vida_boheme

August 26 2008, 11:43:30 UTC 3 years ago

So, yeah, to my chagrin I just realised that in my haste to recc this on my lj I didn't actually get around to commenting. *blush*

You know that I adore this and I really can't express how moving I found it. This is tragic in the true meaning of the word, and managed to make me feel heartbroken for all three protagonists.

To use a less elegant phrase: you nailed it. This is right up there with 'Freedom's just another word for nothing left to lose' and for me, it doesn't get better than that.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 16:40:56 UTC 3 years ago

You are such a sweetheart and I thank you for taking a chance and reading something (I know) you would not normally choose. I'm afraid my warning is going to scare a lot of people off, but I felt the need to be honest - the fic is honest and real after all.

I'm thrilled you enjoyed the story! *huge hugs*

[info]liamar13

August 26 2008, 13:30:43 UTC 3 years ago

oh the last line made me tear up. this is very beautifully written and its a really good story but oh it broke my heart for all the missed possibilities.

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 16:41:55 UTC 3 years ago

Thank you so much for your lovely comments. It is heartbreaking, but I'm so glad that you enjoyed it.

[info]fredbassett

August 26 2008, 19:14:05 UTC 3 years ago

Oh my god this was amazing. Heart-rendingly sad, but beautiful at the same time. A really wonderful piece of work. *sniffles*

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 23:02:14 UTC 3 years ago

Thank you for your kind comments. I've been in angsty mode lately, but sometimes in re-watching an episode or studying over screencaps, I'll pick up on some small thing that shows me the depth of what I see between John and Rodney and it leaves me a little sad. But I'm so pleased that you enjoyed it.

[info]argosy

August 26 2008, 22:10:13 UTC 3 years ago

Aw, that was sad and very sweet. Very nicely done. ♥

[info]neevebrody

August 26 2008, 23:04:24 UTC 3 years ago

Thank you very much! I'm so pleased you enjoyed it.

[info]beadattitude

August 27 2008, 04:31:45 UTC 3 years ago

Oh god, honey. That's. That's. Just incredible. Thank you for letting John accept it at the end. The last paragraph is gold.

[info]neevebrody

August 27 2008, 05:09:18 UTC 3 years ago

Thank you. The end was my favorite part, just the two of them with John having nowhere else to hide.

[info]taiteilija

August 27 2008, 20:03:08 UTC 3 years ago

Oh god, sweetheart. What you've created here is one of the most gorgeous pieces of art I've seen for quite some time, and it touches me deeply. You're probably not surprised to hear that I love this and enjoyed reading it a lot. It's brilliantly done and evokes bittersweet feelings - I think Rodney was happy with the life he's led, even though Jennifer wasn't the one, and yet he longs for John. You hit me really hard with that dialogue when Rodney tries to tell John how he feels and fails entirely.

I also cannot tell you how much I'm in love with the last paragraph. I'm reading it again and again while I type this comment.

It's a shame this amazing work isn't getting more attention - which is why I'm going to rec it in my next LJ entry (kick me if I forget).

[info]neevebrody

August 28 2008, 00:41:25 UTC 3 years ago

Oh sweetie, this makes me blush and wibble. I'm thrilled you liked this - I love having someone I can appreciate the dark and angsty side with. You know, I think Rodney was happy with his life... until John returned. A few years later, when the kids got older, I think he realized that he'd found what was missing - maybe he didn't even know something was "missing" so much as he just felt a constant unease, except when he was around John. I ache for the roads not taken here and really I hurt for Jennifer, too. She was smart or intuitive enough to know things weren't perfect and maybe she even suspected after a while that there might be something between Rodney and John, but she knew it was something that was never acted upon, she'd know if that had happened. She just tried to hold on as best she could. And John, always long-suffering and selfless, but without the eyes to see that Rodney could have wanted the same thing he did. I ache for John, with Rodney gone and knowing that all it would have taken would have been a word, or a step into the unknown... but John wasn't willing to let go of what he did have... Rodney's friendship.

The last paragraph was as vivid in my mind as watching it on a screen - that in itself is John's anguish and his healing all in one.

Thank you again, hon. *smooches*

[info]miso_no_tsuki

August 27 2008, 23:30:26 UTC 3 years ago

So beautifully painful to read.
Magnificently done.
That was art.

[info]neevebrody

August 28 2008, 00:46:13 UTC 3 years ago

Thank you so much for your lovely comments. I'm very glad you enjoyed the story and yes, so painful.

[info]goddess47

August 28 2008, 02:13:00 UTC 3 years ago

He had never denied Rodney anything in life… he isn't about to start now.

::sniffle:: Damn, you made me cry..... but it's so.... the way they would do it... giving up what they could have, each making sure not to drive the other away with asking for more than friendship..... they weren't unhappy, they just weren't as happy as they could have been together.... ::more sniffles::

So very nicely done!

[info]neevebrody

August 28 2008, 10:15:16 UTC 3 years ago

giving up what they could have, each making sure not to drive the other away with asking for more than friendship.....

That's such a wonderful way to put it. I think Rodney was probably as happy as he could be with someone other than John. I tried to show this with the family memories. And you're right, this is how they would do it.

I'm really glad you enjoyed the story and I thank you for reading.

[info]agdrgn

August 28 2008, 02:28:11 UTC 3 years ago

Very very moving. Jennifer was glorious. The tale a perfect speculative fiction as might have been published in earlier science fiction magazines. Nice mix of emotion and science fiction.

--Silverthreads

[info]neevebrody

August 28 2008, 10:22:01 UTC 3 years ago

Thank you so much for your lovely comments. I grew up with the old science fiction and devoured anything by Ray Bradbury (still do even though I've read most of his stories a dozen times), so I tried to give it that plausible creep factor. The idea of the chip and Cutters, though, comes from the movie The Final Cut and stars Robin Williams. If you've never seen it, I'd recommend it. Williams is seriously creepy as the Cutter. Thank you again and I've very glad you enjoyed the story.
Previous
← Ctrl← Alt
Next
Ctrl →Alt →
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…